Cinnamon Pumpkin Butter 4oz with mini Pumpkin Scones

We only use fresh ingredients

Gourmet flavored butter


4oz Chocolate or Red Wine butter with 6 heart shaped buttermilk biscuits and butter spreader   $15

Special Offers

*** July/August***

4 oz Mixed Berry Butter with mini Sweet Scones $15

The Edible Island Market

December 2017

Staten Island Museum at Snug Harbor

Some of our wonderful visitors from the day!

*** December***

Candy Cane or
​Gingerbread butter 4oz

with Sweet Scones

Order your favors for your BirthdayHalloween, and Holiday Parties!

What we offer

**wedding and ​shower
to match your theme**

4oz Strawberry  or Orange Butter with
​      Mini Sweet Easter bread $15 

***May Only***

4oz Espresso Butter with
​mini Cinnamon Scones $15

Butter Me Up

Upcoming Events

No events until 2018

We offer a variety of gourmet butter made with all natural, fresh ingredients.  Made to order.  25 flavors to choose from, with new flavors added every month!

​We also offer VEGAN & GRASS FED varieties.

Some of our Butter Me Up crew at a wonderful event.

Staten Island Advance Cookbook Taste-off

March 19, 2017


Cranberry Orange Butter 4oz
   with Cranberry Orange Scones

**Custom Gift Sets -
​ send us a message or call us.

***Ask about our Butter of the Month Club***

Gourmet Flavor​ed Butter


4oz Lemon Sage Butter with

    mini Lemon Scones $15

Expanded Shipping

Telephone:       732-930-1116                                                                                           FREE local delivery
E-mail:  ButterMeUpNJ@gmail.com                                                                                 2 day shipping available

Fig Fest 2017 

The Veranda @ Silver Lake Golf Course

We now ship throughout the U.S. Includes Next day,  2- and 3-day delivery.

*** September***

       4oz Fig Butter with 
mini Sweet Scones $15


4oz Honey Mustard Beer Butter with 8 Mini Irish soda breads $15