​​Signature Flavors
*Garlic Basil    
​*Maple Bacon

*Cranberry Orange 

*Walnut Honey*
*Brown Sugar Cinnamon  *Strawberry *Pesto    
*Sun-dried Tomato Basil​*
*Apple Cinnamon *Blueberry  *Lemon  *Cilantro Lime*

*Whipped Cinnamon Pumpkin*
 *Sriracha Honey*  ​*Espresso*

*Lemon Sage*

*Pecan Praline* *Chocolate*  
​*Honey Mustard Beer*
*Peanut Butter Chocolate*

  *Apple Butter*

*Pumpkin Apple Butter*

*Mixed Berry Jam Butter*


Seasonal Flavors

Gingerbread *Candy Cane

*Fig

****NEW****

*Peach      *Honey Butter

*Celebration Butter and Scones














*Check back often for new flavors


Available sizes
4oz $6.50                 8oz $10.95

Larger sizes available

** VEGAN & GRASS FED varieties available on request


Telephone:       732-930-1116                                                                                    FREE local delivery
E-mail:  ButterMeUpNJ@gmail.com                                                                                2 day shipping available.

Upcoming events...​


November 19th 

Holiday Farmers' Market

Ocean County Parking Garage Lawn

28 Hadley Ave

Toms River, NJ 08753

November 24th 10-3

Holiday Shopping
American Legion

Church Road

Toms River, NJ



December 1st    11am-4pm

The Edible Island Market

Staten Island Museum

1000 Richmond Terrace

Staten Island, NY


December 9th        10am-4pm

Waretown Volunteer Fire Co

117 Wells Mill Rd

Waretown, NJ